| Platinum | Cobblestones |
| Gold | The Old Court Irish Pub & Restaurant |
| Silver | Peddlers Daughter |
| Bronze | Captain John's |
| Top Pick | Forge & Vine |
| Top Pick | Good Thymes |
| Top Pick | Harbor Seafood |
| Top Pick | Jimbo's Famous Roast Beef and Seafood |
| Top Pick | The Irish Cottage Restaurant and Pub |
