| Platinum | Al Fresca Italian Ristorante |
| Gold | TreMonte Pizzeria |
| Silver | Rocco's Restaurant & Bar |
| Bronze | Mangia Mangia Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Capellini's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Grazie |
| Top Pick | Il Ponte |
| Top Pick | Jimmys Restaurant Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rufinas |
| Top Pick | The Chateau |
