| Platinum | George's Delicatessen |
| Gold | Rizzo's Roast Beef and Pizza |
| Silver | Lou's Deli |
| Bronze | Primo Pizza Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jimmy's Pizza Too |
| Top Pick | Mill City Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Owen and Ollie's |
| Top Pick | Santoro's Sub Shop |
| Top Pick | Suppa's Pizza & Subs |
