| Platinum | Yallem Cake Shop |
| Gold | Walmart - Bakery |
| Silver | Market Basket |
| Bronze | Pizzelle Bakery |
| Top Pick | Joyful Treats |
| Top Pick | Luis Custom Cakes and Treats |
| Top Pick | Luis Gonzalez |
| Top Pick | Olympos Bakery |
| Top Pick | Sugar Coated Bakery |
| Top Pick | Two Sisters Bake Shop |
