| Platinum | Heritage Farm Ice Cream & Restaurant |
| Gold | Shaw Farm Dairy |
| Silver | The Sweet Bar |
| Bronze | Kimball Farm Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Ben & Jerry's |
| Top Pick | Jay Gee's Ice Cream & Fun Center |
| Top Pick | Meadowlands Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Mike's Ice Cream Stand |
| Top Pick | Sullivan Farms Homemade Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Sully's Ice Cream Stand |
